Sustainable aviation: Eco-friendly planes and practices

The aviation industry is the lifeblood of global connectivity, fueling economic growth, tourism, and cultural exchanges. However, its rapid expansion has come at a considerable environmental cost. With aviation accounting for approximately 3.5% of global carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions, the sector is under increasing pressure to adopt sustainable practices. This comprehensive article delves deep into the realm of sustainable aviation, exploring eco-friendly aircraft technologies, innovative practices, and the future trajectory of greener flights.

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction: The Environmental Impact of Aviation
  2. Eco-Friendly Aircraft Technologies
  3. Sustainable Airport Practices
  4. Operational Practices for Sustainable Flights
  5. Industry Initiatives and Policies
  6. Future Outlook: Innovations and Challenges
  7. Conclusion: Charting the Path Forward
  8. References

Introduction: The Environmental Impact of Aviation

Aviation has revolutionized the way we live, enabling unprecedented mobility and connecting disparate corners of the globe. However, this progress has a pressing environmental side effect. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) estimates that CO₂ emissions from aviation reached approximately 915 million metric tonnes in 2019. Moreover, aviation contributes to climate change not just through CO₂ emissions but also via nitrogen oxides (NOₓ), water vapor, and contrails, which have additional warming effects.

As global awareness of climate change intensifies, the aviation industry faces the dual challenge of maintaining growth while mitigating its environmental footprint. Sustainability in aviation isn’t merely a regulatory or corporate responsibility; it’s a critical survival imperative. Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach encompassing technological innovation, operational efficiency, and robust policy frameworks.

Eco-Friendly Aircraft Technologies

The backbone of sustainable aviation lies in the development and deployment of eco-friendly aircraft technologies. These innovations aim to reduce emissions, enhance fuel efficiency, and minimize the overall environmental impact of flights.

Electric Planes

Electric propulsion represents a promising frontier in reducing aviation emissions. Electric planes utilize batteries or fuel cells to power electric motors, replacing traditional jet engines. While still in the developmental and early commercial stages, electric aviation offers several advantages:

  • Zero Emissions at Point of Use: Electric planes emit no CO₂ during flight, significantly reducing their carbon footprint.
  • Reduced Noise Pollution: Electric motors operate more quietly than conventional jet engines, minimizing noise pollution around airports and flight paths.
  • Lower Operating Costs: Electric propulsion systems have fewer moving parts, potentially leading to lower maintenance costs and increased reliability.

Notable Developments:

  • Airbus E-Fan X: A hybrid-electric demonstrator project aiming to retrofit a conventional aircraft with electric propulsion.
  • ZeroAvia: Successfully conducted a 100-mile hydrogen-electric flight, showcasing the viability of longer-range electric aviation.
  • Pipistrel Alpha Electro: An electric aircraft primarily used for pilot training, highlighting the practical applications of electric aviation.

Challenges:

  • Battery Density: Current battery technologies lack the energy density required for large-scale commercial flights, limiting the range and payload capacity of electric planes.
  • Infrastructure Needs: Charging infrastructure at airports and the sourcing of clean electricity are critical for the widespread adoption of electric aviation.
  • Cost: High costs associated with batteries and electric propulsion systems remain a barrier to mass adoption.

Hydrogen-Powered Aircraft

Hydrogen propulsion is another visionary technology poised to transform sustainable aviation. Hydrogen can be utilized either in fuel cells to generate electricity or directly burned in combustion engines to produce thrust.

Advantages:

  • Zero CO₂ Emissions: When produced using renewable energy, hydrogen results in zero CO₂ emissions during flight.
  • High Energy Density: Hydrogen boasts a better energy-to-weight ratio compared to batteries, potentially enabling longer ranges and larger payloads.
  • Versatility: Hydrogen can be used in various propulsion systems, including fuel cells and internal combustion engines.

Notable Developments:

  • Airbus ZEROe Concepts: Airbus unveiled three hydrogen-powered aircraft designs aiming for entry into service by 2035.
  • H2FLY and Lilium Collaboration: Developing hydrogen-powered vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) aircraft for urban air mobility.
  • HES Energy Systems: Exploring hydrogen powertrains for regional and commercial aircraft.

Challenges:

  • Storage and Handling: Hydrogen requires storage at extremely low temperatures or high pressures, posing technical and safety challenges.
  • Infrastructure Development: Establishing hydrogen production, transportation, and refueling infrastructure at airports is capital-intensive.
  • Cost: Hydrogen production, especially green hydrogen produced via electrolysis using renewable energy, remains expensive.

Hybrid Propulsion Systems

Hybrid-electric propulsion systems combine traditional jet engines with electric motors, aiming to leverage the benefits of both technologies. These systems can operate in various modes, such as using electric power during takeoff and landing while relying on jet engines during cruising.

Advantages:

  • Reduced Emissions: By optimizing the use of electric power, hybrid systems can significantly reduce CO₂ and NOₓ emissions.
  • Fuel Efficiency: Enhanced fuel efficiency through optimized engine performance across different flight phases.
  • Scalability: Applicable to a range of aircraft sizes, from regional jets to larger commercial planes.

Notable Developments:

  • Rolls-Royce and Airbus Collaborative Projects: Developing hybrid-electric propulsion systems for future aircraft models.
  • Rolls-Royce ACCEL Project: Aiming to develop electric aero engines with hybrid capabilities for high-speed flight.

Challenges:

  • Complexity: Integrating dual propulsion systems increases aircraft complexity, requiring advanced control systems and redundant safety measures.
  • Weight: Additional components such as batteries and electric motors add weight, possibly affecting performance and efficiency.
  • Certification: Hybrid systems must undergo rigorous testing and certification processes, which can be time-consuming and costly.

Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF)

Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF) are biofuels or synthetic fuels designed to be drop-in replacements for conventional jet fuel. Produced from sustainable feedstocks like plant oils, municipal waste, or even captured CO₂, SAFs aim to reduce the lifecycle carbon emissions of aviation.

Advantages:

  • Carbon Reduction: SAFs can reduce lifecycle CO₂ emissions by up to 80% compared to traditional jet fuels, depending on the feedstock and production process.
  • Compatibility: Designed to be fully compatible with existing aircraft engines and infrastructure, facilitating easier adoption.
  • Energy Density: Similar energy density to conventional jet fuel, enabling longer ranges without significant modifications to aircraft design.

Notable Developments:

  • Neste and World Energy: Leading producers of SAF, supplying to major airlines like Delta, United, and KLM.
  • Gevo and LanzaJet: Developing advanced SAF production processes utilizing renewable feedstocks and innovative technologies.
  • SkyNRG: A key player in SAF sourcing and supply chain development, partnering with various stakeholders to scale up production.

Challenges:

  • Cost: SAFs are currently more expensive to produce than conventional jet fuels, primarily due to limited production scales and high feedstock costs.
  • Feedstock Availability: Sourcing sufficient sustainable feedstocks without competing with food production or causing land-use changes is a critical challenge.
  • Scaling Production: Significant investment and infrastructure development are required to scale SAF production to meet global aviation demand.

Advanced Aerodynamics and Lightweight Materials

Improving aircraft aerodynamics and utilizing lightweight materials are critical in enhancing fuel efficiency and reducing emissions.

Advanced Aerodynamics:

  • Winglets: Additions like winglets reduce aerodynamic drag, improving fuel efficiency by up to 5%.
  • Laminar Flow Control: Maintaining smooth airflow over the wings and fuselage minimizes drag, enhancing fuel efficiency.
  • Blended Wing Body (BWB) Designs: Integrating wings and fuselage into a single aerodynamic structure reduces drag and weight.

Lightweight Materials:

  • Composite Materials: Usage of carbon-fiber-reinforced polymers (CFRP) and other composites significantly reduces aircraft weight compared to traditional aluminum alloys.
  • Titanium and Advanced Alloys: Incorporating lightweight metals in critical structural components offers strength without excessive weight.
  • Additive Manufacturing (3D Printing): Enables the production of lightweight, complex components that traditional manufacturing methods cannot achieve.

Notable Developments:

  • Boeing 787 Dreamliner and Airbus A350: Both aircraft utilize extensive composite materials, resulting in a weight reduction of up to 20% compared to previous models.
  • Lockheed Martin’s Hybrid Wing Body: Exploring innovative designs that integrate structural efficiency with advanced aerodynamics.
  • GE’s Advanced Turboprop Engines: Designed for regional aircraft, combining lightweight materials with aerodynamic enhancements to improve efficiency.

Challenges:

  • Cost: Advanced materials like composites and titanium are more expensive than traditional materials, impacting overall aircraft costs.
  • Manufacturing Complexity: Producing and assembling lightweight, aerodynamic components requires specialized manufacturing processes and expertise.
  • Maintenance and Repair: Composite materials present new challenges for maintenance and repair, necessitating specialized training and facilities.

Sustainable Airport Practices

Airports play a pivotal role in the sustainability of aviation, serving as hubs for implementing eco-friendly practices that extend beyond aircraft operations.

Carbon Offsetting and Reduction

Carbon offsetting involves compensating for emissions by investing in environmental projects such as reforestation, renewable energy, or methane capture.

Carbon Reduction Initiatives:

  • Renewable Energy Projects: Airports can invest in solar panels, wind turbines, and other renewable energy sources to power airport operations.
  • Energy Efficiency Upgrades: Implementing energy-efficient lighting, heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems to reduce energy consumption.
  • Carbon Offsetting Programs: Encouraging airlines and passengers to offset their carbon emissions through verified carbon offset programs.

Notable Developments:

  • Heathrow Airport: Committed to becoming carbon neutral by 2050, investing in renewable energy and carbon offset projects.
  • San Francisco International Airport (SFO): Achieved carbon neutrality for its ground transportation fleet and continues to expand its renewable energy initiatives.
  • Changi Airport Group: Implements comprehensive sustainability strategies, including carbon offsetting and energy-efficient operations.

Efficient Ground Operations

Optimizing ground operations can significantly reduce emissions and energy consumption at airports.

Strategies:

  • Electric Ground Support Equipment (GSE): Replacing diesel-powered baggage tugs, forklifts, and other ground support equipment with electric alternatives.
  • Tarmac Electrification: Providing electric power to aircraft while parked (Electric Ground Power Units) to reduce the need for auxiliary power units running on jet fuel.
  • Optimized Gate Assignments: Reducing taxiing distances and times by efficiently assigning gates and runway slots.

Notable Developments:

  • Denver International Airport: Transitioning its entire ground support fleet to electric vehicles, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and noise.
  • Los Angeles International Airport (LAX): Implementing electric GSE and enhancing tarmac electrification infrastructure to lower emissions.
  • Amsterdam Schiphol Airport: Pioneering the use of electric buses and ground vehicles, alongside initiatives for sustainable ground operations.

Renewable Energy Integration

Harnessing renewable energy sources at airports can drastically cut down operational emissions.

Implementation:

  • Solar Farms: Large-scale solar installations on airport property or adjacent land to generate clean electricity.
  • Wind Turbines: Utilizing wind energy where feasible, depending on geographical location and wind availability.
  • Geothermal Energy: Exploring geothermal sources for heating and cooling needs within airport facilities.

Notable Developments:

  • Atlanta Hartsfield-Jackson Airport: One of the largest on-airport solar installations in the world, powering a significant portion of its energy needs.
  • London Gatwick Airport: Investing in solar energy projects and exploring wind energy opportunities to augment its renewable energy portfolio.
  • Sydney Kingsford Smith Airport: Incorporating solar panels across various terminals and operational areas to harness renewable energy.

Waste Management and Recycling

Effective waste management at airports reduces environmental impact and promotes sustainability.

Strategies:

  • Recycling Programs: Comprehensive recycling initiatives for paper, plastics, metals, and electronics within airport facilities.
  • Composting Organic Waste: Diverting organic waste from landfills by composting food waste generated by restaurants and concession stands.
  • Waste-to-Energy Technologies: Converting non-recyclable waste into energy through incineration with energy capture or anaerobic digestion.

Notable Developments:

  • Singapore Changi Airport: Implements extensive recycling programs and has achieved high waste diversion rates through composting and recycling.
  • Frankfurt Airport: Utilizes waste-to-energy plants to manage its landfill waste, contributing to energy generation and waste reduction.
  • Incheon International Airport: Incorporates advanced waste management systems, including automated sorting and recycling facilities, to enhance sustainability.

Operational Practices for Sustainable Flights

Beyond technological advancements, optimizing flight operations is crucial for reducing the environmental impact of aviation.

Flight Route Optimization

Efficient flight routing can lead to significant fuel savings and emission reductions.

Strategies:

  • Dynamic Routing: Adjusting flight paths in real-time based on weather conditions, air traffic, and airspace restrictions to minimize fuel consumption.
  • Direct Routing: Reducing the number of waypoints and optimizing trajectories to shorten flight distances.
  • Collaborative Decision Making (CDM): Enhancing coordination between airlines, air traffic controllers, and airports to optimize flight flows and reduce delays.

Notable Developments:

  • NextGen (Next Generation Air Transportation System): Implemented in the United States, NextGen focuses on modernizing air traffic control with satellite-based navigation, enabling more precise and efficient flight paths.
  • Single European Sky (SES) Initiative: Aims to reform European airspace management, promoting more direct routing and efficient flight operations across the continent.
  • Performance-Based Navigation (PBN): Global initiative enhancing the precision of flight paths, reducing deviations and enhancing fuel efficiency.

Weight Reduction Measures

Minimizing aircraft weight enhances fuel efficiency and reduces emissions.

Strategies:

  • Lightweight Materials: Utilizing composites, aluminum alloys, and other lightweight materials in aircraft construction.
  • Cabin Optimization: Designing interior components and seating arrangements to minimize weight without compromising passenger comfort.
  • Cargo Efficiency: Implementing lightweight cargo containers and optimizing loading procedures to reduce excess weight.

Notable Developments:

  • Boeing 787 and Airbus A350: Pioneering the extensive use of composite materials to achieve substantial weight reductions.
  • Airbus A220: Marketed as the world’s most efficient single-aisle jet, largely due to its lightweight construction and advanced materials.
  • Embraer E-Jet E2 Series: Incorporates lightweight materials and design efficiencies to enhance fuel performance.

Single-Engine Taxiing

Reducing the use of multiple engines during taxiing can lower fuel consumption and emissions.

Strategies:

  • Auxiliary Power Unit (APU) Optimization: Minimizing APU usage by connecting to ground power when available.
  • Single-Engine Operations: Using only one engine for taxiing instead of multiple engines, where feasible and safe.
  • Electric Taxiing Systems: Developing electric taxiing systems that allow aircraft to move on the ground without engine power.

Notable Developments:

  • Rolls-Royce and Moog Aeronautics: Collaborating on electric taxiing systems that provide electric propulsion for taxi operations, reducing engine use and emissions.
  • Lufthansa: Implementing single-engine taxiing practices on select aircraft and routes to enhance efficiency.
  • Airbus Single Engine Taxi Technology: Researching methods to enable taxis with a single engine while maintaining safety standards.

Continuous Descent Approaches

Continuous Descent Approaches (CDAs) promote smoother and more fuel-efficient descents, reducing emissions during landing.

Strategies:

  • Optimized Descent Profiles: Allowing aircraft to descend gradually without the need for level flight segments, minimizing fuel burn.
  • Real-Time Data Utilization: Leveraging real-time weather and air traffic data to optimize descent paths dynamically.
  • Reduced Thrust Settings: Lowering engine thrust during descent to decrease fuel consumption and emissions.

Notable Developments:

  • CD Shows Initiative: The Carbon Delta Shows Program focuses on implementing continuous descent operations at select airports to demonstrate environmental benefits.
  • Seattle-Tacoma International Airport (SEA): Adopted CDAs to reduce fuel burn and noise pollution during landings.
  • London Heathrow Airport: Utilizing CDAs in conjunction with advanced air traffic management to enhance landing efficiency.

Industry Initiatives and Policies

Sustainable aviation requires collective action, driven by industry initiatives and supportive policies that promote greener practices.

CORSIA

The Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA) is a global initiative led by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO).

Key Features:

  • Emission Offsetting: Requires airlines to offset the growth in their CO₂ emissions above 2020 levels by investing in environmental projects.
  • Phased Implementation: Begins with a pilot phase (2021-2023) followed by a first phase (2024-2026) and subsequent phases for expanding participation.
  • Global Scope: Applies to all international flights, with exemptions for least developed countries and small island states.

Impact:

  • Emission Management: Aims to stabilize aviation emissions at 2020 levels, preventing further growth.
  • Funding for Sustainability Projects: Generates funds for global emission reduction and sustainable development projects.
  • Market Incentives: Encourages airlines to adopt more efficient technologies and practices to minimize offsetting needs.

Challenges:

  • Compliance and Enforcement: Ensuring all participating airlines comply with offsetting requirements.
  • Effectiveness of Offsets: Assessing the actual environmental benefits of offset projects and preventing double-counting.
  • Scope Limitations: CORSIA primarily addresses CO₂ emissions, neglecting other greenhouse gases and non-CO₂ effects of aviation.

Airlines’ Sustainability Commitments

Many airlines have set ambitious sustainability goals to reduce their environmental impact, driven by consumer demand and regulatory pressures.

Common Commitments:

  • Carbon Neutrality Goals: Pledges to achieve carbon neutrality by specific target years, often through a combination of emissions reductions and offsetting.
  • Increased SAF Usage: Commitments to source a certain percentage of their fuel needs from sustainable aviation fuels.
  • Fleet Modernization: Investments in newer, more fuel-efficient aircraft with advanced technologies.
  • Operational Efficiency: Initiatives to optimize flight operations, reduce waste, and enhance overall efficiency.

Notable Examples:

  • British Airways: Targets net-zero carbon emissions by 2050, investing in SAF, fleet renewal, and carbon offsetting.
  • Delta Air Lines: Committed to carbon neutrality, increased SAF adoption, and investments in sustainable infrastructure.
  • Qantas: Aims for net-zero emissions by 2050, with interim targets and investments in emerging technologies like electric and hydrogen aircraft.

Challenges:

  • Financial Constraints: Significant investments are required to achieve ambitious sustainability targets.
  • Technology Maturity: Many proposed technologies are still under development and may not be commercially viable within desired timelines.
  • Market Dynamics: Fluctuating fuel prices and economic pressures can impact the implementation of sustainability initiatives.

Government Regulations and Incentives

Governments play a crucial role in shaping the sustainability landscape of aviation through regulations, incentives, and infrastructure support.

Regulatory Measures:

  • Emission Standards: Implementing strict emission limits for aircraft engines and operational practices.
  • Mandates for SAF: Requiring or incentivizing the use of sustainable aviation fuels within the aviation sector.
  • Subsidies and Grants: Providing financial support for research, development, and deployment of sustainable aviation technologies.

Incentive Programs:

  • Tax Credits: Offering tax incentives for airlines that adopt low-emission technologies or use SAF.
  • Research Funding: Allocating funds for innovation in electric, hydrogen, and hybrid propulsion systems.
  • Infrastructure Investment: Supporting the development of renewable energy sources and hydrogen refueling infrastructure at airports.

Notable Initiatives:

  • European Union’s Fit for 55 Package: Includes measures to reduce aviation emissions, promote SAF, and implement the Emissions Trading System (ETS) for aviation.
  • United States’ Federal Aviation Administration (FAA): Funding programs focused on sustainable aviation research and the integration of eco-friendly technologies.
  • Japan’s Green Growth Strategy: Prioritizes the development of hydrogen-powered aviation and investments in sustainable fuel production.

Challenges:

  • International Coordination: Aligning policies and standards across different countries to ensure a cohesive global approach.
  • Economic Implications: Balancing environmental goals with economic considerations and the competitiveness of the aviation industry.
  • Technology Adoption: Ensuring that regulatory frameworks keep pace with technological advancements and facilitate their integration.

Future Outlook: Innovations and Challenges

The path to sustainable aviation is promising yet fraught with challenges. Continued innovation and collective action will be paramount in overcoming barriers and achieving meaningful progress.

Innovations on the Horizon

  1. Blended Wing Body (BWB) Aircraft:
  2. Description: A design where the wings and body are integrated into a single aerodynamic form, improving fuel efficiency.
  3. Prospects: Companies like Boeing and Airbus are researching BWB designs, which could revolutionize aircraft performance and capacity.

  4. Autonomous and Semi-Autonomous Flight Operations:

  5. Description: Incorporating AI and automation in flight operations to optimize performance and reduce human error.
  6. Prospects: Enhanced flight path optimization, fuel efficiency, and reduced operational costs through autonomous systems.

  7. Energy Storage Advancements:

  8. Description: Breakthroughs in battery technology and alternative energy storage methods like solid-state batteries.
  9. Prospects: Higher energy density and faster charging could make electric and hybrid aircraft more viable for commercial use.

  10. Repurposing Aircraft Components:

  11. Description: Recycling and repurposing materials from decommissioned aircraft to reduce waste and resource consumption.
  12. Prospects: Enhances the circular economy within the aviation sector and mitigates the environmental impact of aircraft manufacturing and disposal.

  13. Advanced Air Traffic Management Systems:

  14. Description: Implementing AI and machine learning in air traffic control to enhance flight efficiency.
  15. Prospects: Reduced delays, optimized routing, and lower fuel consumption through intelligent traffic management.

Challenges Facing Sustainable Aviation

  1. Technological Hurdles:
  2. Battery Limitations: Current battery technologies are inadequate for large-scale commercial flights, necessitating breakthroughs in energy density and safety.
  3. Hydrogen Infrastructure: Developing a viable hydrogen supply chain for aviation is capital-intensive and technologically challenging.

  4. Economic Barriers:

  5. High Costs: Developing and deploying sustainable aviation technologies require substantial investments, which may be difficult to secure without regulatory support or market incentives.
  6. Market Volatility: Fluctuating fuel prices and economic uncertainties can impact the stability and predictability required for long-term investments in sustainability.

  7. Regulatory and Policy Constraints:

  8. Lack of Global Standards: Inconsistent regulations across regions can hinder the global implementation of sustainable practices.
  9. Policy Lag: Regulatory frameworks often lag behind technological advancements, delaying the adoption of new sustainable technologies.

  10. Supply Chain and Resource Constraints:

  11. Material Scarcity: The production of sustainable technologies may be limited by the availability of critical materials like rare earth elements required for batteries and fuel cells.
  12. Sustainable Feedstock Limitations: Ensuring a consistent and sustainable supply of feedstocks for SAF without impacting food security or ecosystem balance is challenging.

  13. Public Acceptance and Behavioral Change:

  14. Passenger Preferences: Balancing sustainability with passenger comfort and expectations can influence the acceptance of new technologies and practices.
  15. Awareness and Education: Ensuring that passengers understand and support sustainability initiatives requires effective communication and education efforts.

Conclusion: Charting the Path Forward

Sustainable aviation encapsulates a multifaceted approach, intertwining technological innovation, operational efficiency, and robust policy frameworks to mitigate the environmental impact of flights. While significant progress has been made in developing eco-friendly aircraft technologies, optimizing flight operations, and implementing sustainable airport practices, the journey towards truly sustainable aviation is ongoing and demanding.

Collaboration across the aviation ecosystem — including airlines, manufacturers, governments, and passengers — is essential to drive the necessary changes. Investment in research and development, coupled with supportive regulatory environments, can accelerate the adoption of sustainable practices and technologies. Additionally, fostering a global consensus on emission reduction targets and sustainability standards will ensure cohesive progress across international boundaries.

The future of aviation lies in harmonizing the sector’s intrinsic need for connectivity with the planet’s imperative for sustainability. Through continued innovation, concerted efforts, and unwavering commitment, the skies can become not only a symbol of human achievement but also a testament to our dedication to preserving the environment for generations to come.

References

  1. International Air Transport Association (IATA) – Reports on aviation emissions and sustainability initiatives.
  2. International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) – Documents and updates on CORSIA and global aviation standards.
  3. Airbus and Boeing Press Releases – Information on new aircraft models and sustainability projects.
  4. Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) Industry Reports – Analysis of SAF production, usage, and market trends.
  5. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) – Data on aviation’s environmental impact and regulatory measures.
  6. Research Articles from Journals like Aerospace Science and Technology – In-depth studies on sustainable aviation technologies and practices.

This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of sustainable aviation, encapsulating current advancements, industry initiatives, and the road ahead. For more detailed insights, readers are encouraged to explore the referenced materials and stay updated with ongoing developments in the field.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *